Road Maintenance Triage: How California Cities Decide Which Streets Get Fixed First

Behind every newly paved street is a series of decisions about infrastructure, public safety, financial priorities, and the long-term cost of maintaining California’s roads.

THE CIVIC COMMONS | Infrastructure & Public Policy


There is a familiar frustration in almost every California community. A residential street develops cracks and potholes that seem to grow worse with each passing year. Residents report the damage, sometimes repeatedly, yet little appears to change. Then, seemingly without warning, construction crews arrive to resurface a nearby road that looks considerably better.

The question is understandable: Why was that street repaired while ours continues to deteriorate?

For residents, the condition of the street outside their homes is among the most visible measures of local government’s performance. Roads are used every day, and their deterioration is difficult to ignore. Unlike many municipal services, pavement conditions provide an immediate, tangible reminder of whether public infrastructure is being maintained.

Yet the decisions determining which streets receive attention are considerably more complicated than appearances suggest.

Most California cities operate within a framework of pavement management, infrastructure planning, financial limitations, and competing transportation needs. Rather than simply identifying the worst streets and repairing them in order, public works departments attempt to manage an entire road network in a way that preserves its usefulness while minimizing long-term costs.

This means a street in relatively good condition may receive maintenance before one that has already deteriorated significantly. A heavily traveled arterial may be prioritized over a residential neighborhood. A road scheduled for underground utility replacement may be deliberately left untouched until that work is completed.

These decisions can appear counterintuitive, particularly to residents living with deteriorating pavement. But they reflect an important distinction between repairing individual streets and maintaining a transportation system.

Understanding that distinction helps explain how cities allocate limited resources, why preventive maintenance matters, and what residents should reasonably expect from their local governments.

Roads Are Assets That Require Continuous Management

A city’s road network represents one of its largest and most expensive public assets.

Streets connect neighborhoods to schools, workplaces, commercial districts, hospitals, and public facilities. They accommodate passenger vehicles, commercial trucks, emergency responders, public transportation, cyclists, and pedestrians.

Their condition affects more than driving comfort. Poor pavement can increase vehicle maintenance costs, create safety hazards, interfere with emergency response, and eventually impose substantial financial obligations on local governments.

Unlike buildings or other public facilities, streets are exposed continuously to traffic loads, temperature changes, water infiltration, and environmental conditions.

In California’s Central Valley, intense summer heat, winter rainfall, agricultural transportation, heavy commercial vehicles, and local soil conditions can all influence pavement performance. Underground utility work, inadequate drainage, and the cumulative effects of repeated repairs introduce additional complications.

Different streets experience these pressures differently.

A residential cul-de-sac serving a few dozen homes may experience relatively light traffic. A major arterial carrying thousands of vehicles, including buses and delivery trucks, may accumulate substantial wear despite having been constructed to a higher standard.

Managing these assets requires information about their condition, expected deterioration, and the cost of maintaining or replacing them.

That is the purpose of a pavement management system.

The Pavement Condition Index: Putting a Number on Road Quality

Many California municipalities use a Pavement Management System, commonly abbreviated PMS, to inventory streets, evaluate their condition, estimate future deterioration, and identify appropriate maintenance treatments.

One of the central measurements used in these systems is the Pavement Condition Index, or PCI.

PCI provides a numerical assessment of pavement condition on a scale from zero to 100, where 100 represents pavement in excellent condition and zero represents complete failure.

The standardized PCI methodology described in ASTM D6433 evaluates visible pavement distress, including the type, extent, and severity of cracking, surface deterioration, potholes, rutting, and other forms of damage.

Agencies may use slightly different descriptive categories, but a typical interpretation is:

  • 86–100: Good. Pavement generally requires monitoring and relatively inexpensive preventive maintenance.
  • 71–85: Satisfactory. The roadway remains serviceable and may benefit from preservation treatments that extend its useful life.
  • 56–70: Fair. More substantial deterioration is appearing, and timely intervention becomes increasingly important.
  • 41–55: Poor. The pavement may require significant rehabilitation depending on the nature and severity of the damage.
  • 40 and below: Very poor to failed. Major rehabilitation or reconstruction may be necessary, although the appropriate treatment depends on the underlying structural condition.

PCI is not a direct measurement of every aspect of street performance. A smooth roadway can conceal structural weaknesses, while a visibly rough street may remain structurally sound. Ride quality, drainage, traffic loading, and pavement structure may require separate evaluation.

Still, PCI provides a useful and relatively consistent method for comparing streets across a large transportation network.

Historically, pavement assessments relied heavily on visual inspections conducted by trained personnel. These methods remain useful, but cities increasingly have access to specialized survey vehicles equipped with high-resolution cameras, laser measurement systems, and other technologies capable of documenting surface conditions.

The resulting information can be incorporated into pavement management software, which helps estimate deterioration and compare possible maintenance strategies.

For California cities, StreetSaver, developed by the Metropolitan Transportation Commission, is one example of a pavement management platform used to support these decisions.

The important advantage is not simply that streets receive a numerical score. It is that cities can evaluate the consequences of different investments before committing public funds.

A Local Illustration: Turlock’s Road Network

Turlock, in Stanislaus County, provides an example of why pavement management matters for growing Central Valley communities.

Citywide pavement assessments have identified an average PCI of approximately 62, placing the overall network within the commonly used fair-condition category.

An average, however, can conceal substantial differences.

Some streets may remain in satisfactory or good condition, while others are approaching the point where significant rehabilitation or reconstruction becomes necessary.

The average PCI does not reveal how much of the network is in each condition category, how quickly individual segments are deteriorating, or whether the city’s available funding is sufficient to prevent additional decline.

These distinctions are essential.

A city may maintain an average PCI in the 60s while still carrying a substantial backlog of expensive reconstruction projects. Conversely, an improving average may indicate that preservation investments are beginning to stabilize the network even though some severely deteriorated streets remain unrepaired.

Turlock, like other municipalities, must translate pavement assessments into practical maintenance schedules and longer-term capital improvement priorities.

The difficulty is not simply identifying which roads need work. It is determining which combination of projects will produce the greatest long-term benefit within the resources available.

Why Fixing the Worst Roads First Can Be the Wrong Strategy

At first glance, road maintenance would seem to follow a straightforward principle: repair the streets in the worst condition before spending money on those that are still serviceable.

There is a certain logic to this approach. Residents experiencing the greatest deterioration have an understandable expectation that their streets should receive attention.

But pavement deterioration does not progress at a constant rate.

During the earlier portion of a pavement’s life, relatively minor problems can often be addressed through inexpensive maintenance. Small cracks can be sealed before water penetrates the pavement structure. Surface treatments can help protect the asphalt from weathering and additional deterioration.

As damage accumulates, however, the cost of restoring the roadway rises.

Water may penetrate through cracks and weaken the underlying pavement layers. Repeated traffic loads can enlarge structural defects. What begins as relatively minor surface distress can eventually develop into extensive cracking, potholes, and pavement failure.

Once deterioration reaches that stage, preventive treatments are no longer sufficient.

The roadway may require removal and replacement of the asphalt surface, repairs to its underlying structure, or complete reconstruction.

The financial difference can be substantial.

Crack sealing and surface preservation treatments generally cost far less than asphalt overlays, while full reconstruction can be many times more expensive than either.

The exact costs depend on pavement thickness, road width, site conditions, labor, materials, and the type of treatment required. But the underlying relationship remains consistent: preventing structural failure is generally less expensive than rebuilding pavement after it fails.

Consider two streets.

The first has a PCI of 75. It remains in satisfactory condition, but surface cracking suggests that preventive treatment would be beneficial. A relatively inexpensive maintenance project could protect the pavement and extend its useful life.

The second has a PCI of 35. Significant structural deterioration has occurred, and surface treatments alone are unlikely to restore its condition. Rehabilitation or reconstruction may be required.

If a city spends its entire maintenance budget rebuilding the second street, it may have insufficient resources to preserve dozens of streets that remain in better condition.

Those streets will continue to deteriorate, potentially creating an even larger financial problem.

This is why modern pavement management generally emphasizes a balanced strategy.

Cities must preserve roads that remain serviceable while also addressing structural failures, safety hazards, and the most pressing rehabilitation needs.

The challenge is deciding how to distribute funding between those competing responsibilities.

A preservation-heavy strategy may improve the long-term financial performance of the network but leave residents on severely deteriorated streets feeling overlooked. A reconstruction-heavy strategy may deliver visible improvements in the worst locations while allowing the broader system to decline.

Neither extreme is necessarily sustainable.

Effective pavement management attempts to avoid both.

How Cities Decide Which Streets Receive Priority

PCI provides an important starting point, but pavement condition alone rarely determines the final maintenance schedule.

Cities must consider how individual streets function within the transportation network, the risks associated with continued deterioration, and the practical costs of completing proposed work.

These considerations frequently overlap.

Traffic Volume and Street Classification

Not every street serves the same purpose.

Transportation networks are generally organized into functional classifications, including arterial roads, collectors, and local streets.

Arterials accommodate larger volumes of traffic and connect major destinations. Collectors move traffic between neighborhoods and arterial routes. Local streets primarily provide access to residences and individual properties.

A deteriorating arterial may affect thousands of daily trips, while a similarly deteriorated residential street affects a smaller number of users.

This difference can influence investment priorities.

Traffic volume is not the only consideration, however. Vehicle weight, particularly repeated heavy-truck loading, can have a disproportionate effect on pavement deterioration.

A road serving industrial facilities, agricultural operations, or major freight routes may require different maintenance considerations than one primarily used by passenger vehicles.

Functional classification therefore helps cities evaluate both the public impact of road conditions and the engineering requirements of maintaining them.

Safety and Accessibility

Safety considerations can move a street or individual hazard higher on the priority list regardless of its PCI.

Deep potholes, pavement failures, drainage problems, and hazardous surface conditions may create immediate risks for motorists, cyclists, pedestrians, and emergency responders.

Areas surrounding schools, transit stops, senior facilities, and other heavily used destinations may require additional consideration.

Accessibility also matters.

A pavement defect that presents a minor inconvenience to a passenger vehicle may create a much greater problem for someone using a bicycle, wheelchair, or other mobility device.

These concerns help explain why road maintenance cannot be reduced to a single numerical ranking.

Some conditions require a prompt operational response, even when the street itself is not scheduled for comprehensive rehabilitation.

The Long-Term Return on Investment

Another major factor is the expected benefit of a proposed treatment relative to its cost.

Pavement management software can help compare treatment alternatives, estimate their useful lives, and model their effects on the overall network.

A preservation project costing relatively little may extend the serviceable life of a large amount of pavement.

A reconstruction project may deliver a greater improvement to an individual street but consume a much larger share of the budget.

Both may be justified.

The question is how each project contributes to the city’s broader infrastructure goals.

This is particularly important when a city faces a substantial maintenance backlog.

A limited annual budget may not be sufficient to improve every deficient street. Officials must therefore consider which investments will prevent the greatest future deterioration while continuing to address roads that have already reached critical condition.

Coordination With Utilities and Other Projects

Road work rarely occurs in isolation.

Underground water lines, sewer systems, storm drains, telecommunications facilities, and other infrastructure frequently occupy the same corridors.

Resurfacing a street immediately before a major utility replacement would be inefficient. Newly installed pavement might have to be excavated, producing additional costs and unnecessary disruption.

For this reason, public works departments attempt to coordinate pavement projects with planned utility improvements.

Construction schedules may also be adjusted to combine nearby projects, reduce contractor mobilization costs, or minimize repeated traffic disruptions.

A street may therefore be delayed not because it lacks importance, but because another infrastructure project must be completed first.

These decisions can be difficult to communicate to residents, particularly when the reasons for postponement are not publicly visible.

Equity and Community Need

Infrastructure decisions also raise questions about geographic fairness.

Historically, some neighborhoods have experienced longer periods of deferred maintenance than others. Differences in development history, street design, municipal investment, and local conditions can contribute to uneven pavement quality across a city.

Some California municipalities incorporate equity considerations into infrastructure planning to help identify communities experiencing disproportionate infrastructure deficiencies.

San Diego, for example, has included community conditions and equity considerations in its broader pavement management and infrastructure discussions.

Equity does not necessarily mean that every neighborhood receives an identical amount of funding each year.

Street mileage, pavement condition, traffic volumes, construction costs, and infrastructure needs vary substantially across neighborhoods.

Instead, an equitable approach should make the distribution of public investment understandable and ensure that residents are not systematically disadvantaged by factors unrelated to legitimate infrastructure priorities.

The goal is to balance measurable need with fair access to public services.

From Pavement Data to Construction Projects

Once street conditions have been assessed, cities must translate technical information into a realistic work program.

This generally begins with an inventory of the road network divided into individual pavement segments.

Condition assessments identify existing deterioration. Pavement management models then estimate how conditions may change over time under different maintenance and funding scenarios.

The resulting information helps departments identify candidate projects.

However, a software-generated recommendation is not necessarily a final construction schedule.

Engineers must consider whether the proposed treatment is appropriate, whether underground infrastructure work is pending, and whether the project can be completed within available funding.

Maintenance projects may then be organized into annual programs, while larger rehabilitation and reconstruction projects are incorporated into a multiyear Capital Improvement Program.

The Capital Improvement Program, or CIP, allows cities to identify major infrastructure investments, estimate costs, establish funding sources, and plan implementation over several years.

Projects generally remain subject to budget availability, engineering review, environmental or regulatory requirements where applicable, and construction scheduling.

City councils play an important role in this process.

Their responsibility is primarily to establish policy direction, approve budgets, adopt infrastructure priorities, and provide oversight of municipal performance.

Technical staff generally evaluate pavement conditions and recommend appropriate engineering treatments.

The distinction matters.

Elected officials should be accountable for the policies and resources guiding infrastructure maintenance, while project selection should remain grounded in defensible technical criteria rather than political influence alone.

A well-functioning system requires both professional expertise and democratic accountability.

Pothole Repairs Are Not the Same as Street Rehabilitation

One of the most common sources of confusion involves the difference between routine pothole repairs and planned pavement rehabilitation.

Although both involve street maintenance, they operate on different timelines and serve different purposes.

Pothole repairs are typically part of a city’s ongoing maintenance operations.

When a dangerous pavement defect is reported, public works personnel may evaluate the hazard and schedule an appropriate response. Immediate safety concerns can receive priority over less urgent maintenance requests.

Crews may also group repairs geographically to reduce travel time, improve productivity, and make efficient use of available materials.

Full street rehabilitation is different.

An overlay or reconstruction project generally requires engineering analysis, cost estimates, funding authorization, and contractor scheduling.

These projects may be planned months or years in advance.

Consequently, a city might repair a pothole on a street that is not scheduled for resurfacing while allowing another deteriorated street to remain in the capital improvement queue.

These are not necessarily inconsistent decisions.

One addresses an immediate maintenance condition. The other involves the long-term rehabilitation of an infrastructure asset.

Understanding these separate processes can help residents make more effective requests and better interpret the city’s response.

California’s Persistent Road Funding Challenge

Even with sophisticated pavement management systems, municipalities face a basic financial constraint: roadway needs can exceed the money available to address them.

California cities generally rely on combinations of state transportation revenues, local funds, and other eligible sources to support pavement maintenance and rehabilitation.

Senate Bill 1, the Road Repair and Accountability Act of 2017, established additional transportation revenues for road maintenance and related purposes, including allocations supporting local streets and roads.

Some communities also benefit from voter-approved local transportation measures.

In Stanislaus County, Measure L, approved by voters in 2016, established a local transportation sales tax intended to support eligible transportation improvements, including local street and road programs.

Yet the existence of dedicated funding does not eliminate the challenge of maintaining an aging road network.

Construction costs change over time. Pavement continues to deteriorate. Traffic patterns evolve. Growing cities add new streets that will eventually require maintenance of their own.

At the same time, local governments must fund public safety, parks, water systems, public facilities, and other essential services.

The result is a continuing competition for resources.

A city can increase its maintenance spending and still experience pavement deterioration if its investment remains below the level needed to preserve the network.

This is why the size of an annual road budget tells only part of the story.

What matters is how that investment compares with the actual maintenance need and whether the spending strategy is improving the system’s long-term condition.

The Importance of Measuring Results

Pavement management is most effective when cities use the information not merely to select projects, but to evaluate performance.

A useful public infrastructure report should answer several questions.

Is the average condition of the road network improving, remaining stable, or declining?

How many miles of streets fall into good, fair, poor, or failed condition?

How much deferred maintenance has accumulated, and what would it cost to address?

What level of annual investment would be required to stabilize pavement conditions? What additional funding would be necessary to achieve measurable improvement?

These questions are more revealing than simply announcing how many roads were resurfaced during a particular year.

A municipality might complete a large number of projects while the overall network continues to decline.

Conversely, preventive maintenance may produce fewer highly visible transformations while significantly reducing future infrastructure costs.

Evaluating performance therefore requires looking beyond individual construction projects.

It also requires distinguishing between the condition of the network today and the financial consequences of maintaining current funding levels.

Pavement management software can model these scenarios, allowing city officials to compare the projected outcomes of different budgets and treatment strategies.

Such analysis does not remove the need for policy decisions. It makes the consequences of those decisions easier to understand.

Transparency Makes Infrastructure Decisions More Credible

A technically sound pavement management program can still lose public confidence if residents do not understand how decisions are made.

People are more likely to question a maintenance schedule when they cannot determine why certain streets were selected, why others were deferred, or what criteria shaped the final work program.

Cities can address this problem through accessible reporting.

Publicly available pavement condition maps can help residents understand the status of their streets.

Multiyear maintenance schedules can explain which projects are anticipated and how they relate to available funding.

Clear descriptions of project selection criteria can demonstrate how pavement condition, safety, traffic, cost-effectiveness, and geographic considerations influence priorities.

Just as important, cities should explain when schedules change.

A postponed project may reflect utility conflicts, changes in funding, unexpected structural problems, or construction constraints.

Without that explanation, the delay can appear arbitrary.

Transparency does not require promising that every street will receive immediate attention. It requires explaining the process honestly and giving residents a reasonable understanding of what comes next.

Resident participation also remains valuable.

Pavement assessments provide a systematic view of infrastructure conditions, but public reports can help identify localized hazards, drainage failures, or rapidly developing problems between scheduled inspections.

An effective system combines technical data with public observation rather than treating them as competing sources of information.

Looking Beyond the Next Construction Season

Road maintenance is often discussed one pothole, one neighborhood, or one construction project at a time.

But the underlying challenge extends far beyond an individual maintenance season.

Every street represents a long-term financial obligation. Once constructed, it must eventually be maintained, rehabilitated, and, when necessary, replaced.

A city that continually postpones preventive maintenance may appear to save money in the short term while accumulating considerably larger costs in the future.

Conversely, a city that concentrates exclusively on preserving streets in relatively good condition risks allowing seriously deteriorated neighborhoods to remain underserved.

The most effective strategy requires balancing these responsibilities within a realistic financial framework.

For growing Central Valley communities, that balance is especially important.

New residential development, expanding commercial activity, regional freight movement, and changing transportation patterns can place additional demands on streets that were designed under different conditions.

Planning for those demands requires more than reacting to deterioration after it occurs.

It requires understanding the existing infrastructure, anticipating future needs, coordinating investments, and evaluating whether current policies are financially sustainable.

In that respect, road maintenance is not simply an engineering problem.

It is a test of municipal planning, public accountability, and long-term stewardship.

A Better Question Than “Why Not My Street?”

Residents have every reason to expect safe, functional roads and responsible use of their tax dollars.

When their streets deteriorate, asking why repairs have not been completed is entirely appropriate.

But the larger public conversation benefits from moving beyond the condition of any single roadway.

The more consequential questions are whether the city has a credible pavement management strategy, whether that strategy is supported by adequate funding, and whether measurable results demonstrate that the overall network is improving.

A transparent program should make it possible to understand why one street receives a relatively inexpensive preservation treatment while another waits for major reconstruction.

It should also make clear when a delay reflects an unavoidable financial limitation rather than an effective long-term strategy.

There will always be competing priorities, and no pavement management system can eliminate every difficult decision.

What a well-designed system can do is establish a consistent, understandable framework for making those decisions.

The goal is not simply to repair the greatest number of potholes or produce the longest possible list of completed construction projects.

It is to preserve the public’s investment, maintain safe and dependable transportation infrastructure, and prevent today’s manageable maintenance needs from becoming tomorrow’s expensive failures.

That is the difference between reacting to deteriorating streets and responsibly managing a city’s transportation future.